Awards

 

WINNER! Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical—Outer Critics Circle Award

WINNER! Best Off-Broadway Musical—Broadway World 2009 Theatre Fans’ Choice Award


2010 Lucille Lortel Award Nomination
Outstanding Musical
Outstanding Choreographer—Wendy Seyb
Outstanding Featured Actress—Nancy Opel
Outstanding Sound Design—Kurt Fischer

2009 Drama League Award Nominations
Distinguished Production of a Musical
Distinguished Performance Award—Nancy Opel

2009 Drama Desk Award Nominations
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical—Demond Green
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical—Nancy Opel
Outstanding Book of a Musical—Joe DiPietro
 
2009 Outer Critics Circle Awards Nominations and Winner
Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical (WINNER!)
Outstanding Actress in a Musical—Nancy Opel
2009 Henry Hewes Design Award Nominations
Scenic Design, Beowulf Boritt
Costume Design, David C. Woolard
2009 Joe. A. Callaway Award for Choreography
Finalist—Wendy Seyb for Toxic Avenger Choreography
2010 Dora Award Nominations and Winner
Outstanding Production—The Toxic Avenger
Outstanding Original Choreography—Wendy Seyb
Outstanding Performance by a Male—Evan Smith
Outstanding Performance by a Male—Daren A. Herbert
Outstanding Performance by a Female—Louise Pitre (WINNER!)